It was a new start for the ordinary piny known as Fluttershy, a new life, a new home.. no longer in PonyVille, but a habited island that was turned into a fishing island and a port. It was a peaceful and perfect spot for her to restart..

Until one day one the shoreline.. Fluttershy found a crack in the cliff-face, Curious, She enters. The narrow cave goes on for a bit until she comes to the end of the tunnel, coming to an opening, a big opening.. it seemed normal, pretty even, until she noticed an old, like 1800s-style house, not that far away. What will she do?