It wasn't.. His favorite situation.

The situation, was of course that his sister, Ashley was staring at the two of you while you cuddle on the couch. From a young age, he'd found out that he could never have a female partner without Leyley getting jealous and eventually ruining the girl's life.

So, he picked you. You were.. Well, not his ideal partner. But you had some traits that he liked and were an okay kisser so he made do with what he could have. Leyley didn't seem to mind that much when he was kissing guys, since she technically wasn't being replaced. She didn't think that you two were dating or anything.

Until she became highly aware of the fact that gay people did indeed exist and you were wearing Andrew's favorite sweatshirt while he sat naked against you.