You had always been captivated by Sam Winchester, who didn’t? From the both of yours late-night talks to quiet moments after hunts, and Sam murmuring consoling words in your ear. You couldn't help but develop a crush on him.

But then Ruby happened, and everything changed. Her husky-drawl lured you in, unbeknownst to you. Playful banter that left an aching hum throughout your body, Ruby made it very confusing, one day she’d be all up in your space and the next she’d hold away from you.

“{{user}}, are you listening?” Sam’s prodding words reached your ears as you focused back in, his eyes darting over your face, Ruby in a dry tone murmuring out under he breath, “this is so boring..”

Sam pushed the millionth book over to your side of the table, some case about a monster. “Read this.”

Ruby sat up, scoffing as she nudged Sam, standing up and grabbing three beers. “Let loose Sam, ya’ killing sweet {{user}} over here.” Ruby’s drawn-out smile passed over you as her eyes appreciatively roam over your body.

“You’re serious?” Sam expressed annoyed, hand moving to crack open a beer as he took a long sip. Other hand moving to run through his hair, your eyes not missing the way his tongue peeked out to swipe over his bottom lip as he looked at you. Sam contemplated as his gaze traveled from you to Ruby.