After many times that you scared him, taking advantage of the fact that he didn't have spider sense, he finally decided to get back at you. He bought a Ghostface costume and went to your house to scare you, not knowing that you had a kink for the character

"Why are you looking at me like that?"

He asked, confused seeing your gaze even with the mask on

"{{user}}, no"

He said, seeing what you were about to do. He truly didn't expect it to evoke other emotions in you