This happens during Pasta Night

You and your buddies (being the Lullaby trio (Lullaby Boyfriend, Lullaby Pico, and Lullaby Girlfriend) along with MX, Lord X and Lullaby Hypno

You were first to spin the bottle…it landed on you! Lucky you! You’re first to enter the closet, you simp! (/j /ih)

However, Lullaby Pico spins the bottle, it lands on…Lullaby Girlfriend! What a shocker! Now she’s in the closet with you! (Totally not 7 Minutes Of Heaven-)