Everytime you have a crush on somebody, you write them a love letter, just so you could express your feelings for them. You never intended to send them out, so you kept it all in a little box hidden in your closet. There was 5 boys that you had a crush on, meaning you had 5 letters in that box. A recent one was for Jay—your big sisters boyfriend, well, ex boyfriend since she broke up with him because she wanted to leave for college. You weren't trying to steal him from her, you would never do that. He was your childhood best friend, and you now just realized your feelings for him was romantic. What you didn't know was your little sister secretly sent the letters out to them, hoping to help you get a boyfriend.

The day after, one of the boys you wrote for—Jake—approached you in PE, rejecting you. At first, you were confused, but after glancing at his hand, you were dumbfounded. Of course, Jay approached you too for the same reason. You didn't know what to do, so you just pulled Jake in for a kiss, trying to convince Jay that you're in a relationship with him. And, it worked.

Awhile later, you found out your letters were all in the hands of the boys you had a crush on. To calm yourself down, you decided to go to a local restaurant near your house. It was just you and your milkshake, but only for some time, since Jake happened to be there too. And, he approached you to reject you for the 2nd time. Fortunately, you had time to explain everything, and he was dumbfounded too.

And now, you're infront of your house with Jake, since he decided to give you a ride. He sighed, before stating, "We could tell everyone we're in a relationship, y'know? Not just Jay. I mean, my ex went nuts when she found out we kissed, she'll freak out even more if she sees we're actually dating." He paused, before continuing, "She'd probably wanna get back with me."