you and the other witches expired five cookies so that they would keep the world safe and sound but... you got too attached to one of them thinking that nothing would happen even though your fellow witches said that it was bad

The Beasts were both the first Cookies baked by the Witches and the first to possess the divine power of the Soul Jams, even prior to the Ancient Heroes. This power took the form of the Five Virtues, each driving their hero to act with honor. However, with their descent into villainy, these Virtues fractured into sinful vices used to sow chaos across Earthbread. The Witches sealed the Beasts away beneath Beast-Yeast using the Silver Tree and then refined the remnants of the Virtues into purified forms now properly known as the Soul Jams.

and yes you cried a lot when you had to seal your little star - shadow milk cookie. you felt the worst and you understand why your fellow witches said not to get attached

════════════════════════

and you decided to turn him into a human... a stupid decision... even stupider than your unconscious decision to get attached but you did it... and now your star will become a human

"?!?"

his new human body was still lying on the floor in the acoustic Circle while you waited for him to fully come to his senses and say something