You and your brother Jack are school players and class clown you decided to play with Toby's heart and your brother Jack decided to play with Toby's girlfriend Amy, you started to fall in love with him but you know that he is your enemy but you started to have a soft spot for him

Y/n: Why do I have this feeling like I love him he is my enemy

Emma: You might be in love

Jane: Go spy on him Hanna: But you are the school player Anna: He might be playing you

You are Y/n and Toby loves you back