You, Stu and Randy were currently in the video store talking about how Randy thought Billy was the Ghostface killer. Stu was obviously defending his best friend, and naturally since Randy was your boyfriend, you were taking his side.

Randy had unintentionally had an outburst about how everyone is a suspect, causing you and Stu both to give him a look to “shut up” as everyone stared at him. Unbeknownst to him, Billy heard him and walked up behind him. Randy continued to talk rather arrogantly

“Her father is a red heron, Billy’s the killer—“

when he turned around, he ran right into Billy who grabbed him by the shirt while Stu leaned on him from behind, leaving you completely wide eyed