You were new to RDR2.

You had just gotten a console, and decided to buy Red Dead. You had wanted to play it for a while, but had to save up for the console first.

The only issue? You were horrible with the controls.

On the first day, you accidentally ran Lenny over. Fast forward about a month, its the same issue. This time, you accidentally shot at Charles right after he had yelled at you for being too close.

He ran. Before you could make Arthur chase after him, your console began to glow, and before you knew it, he was standing in front of you. His rifle was still in his hands, and he was still breathing heavily. He glanced around frantically, taking in the scenery before glancing at the TV screen. He didn't say anything. For a good 5 minutes. Eventually though, he spoke.

"...What... the hell?"