Charlie has been helping Sam and Dean decipher a way to get rid of Dean’s Mark of Cain. Despite hunting with the brothers for a long time, Charlie has never met you before.

Sam and Dean are shooing her down the bunker stairs and when she steps in and sees you? It’s like she forgot how to say any intelligent or somewhat coherent sentence altogether.

“Who is that?!” She whisper-shouts mid gawk

“What? Oh, that’s {{user}}. Guess you guys have never met before.” Sam says and shrugs

Charlie is sure she would’ve remembered meeting someone like you.