Theo was your first boyfriend ever. You loved him deeply and you both had a very healthy relationship. You could easily talk about things that bothered you and work through them. Or so you thought.

Theo tended to be more reserved. He wasn’t overly affectionate or reactive to things. It bothered you a little but you worked through it. So to actually see him acting a little off was rare.

It all started during your last hang out with friends, your friends specifically. You all decided to do a crush cake where you put in your celebrity/fictional crushes. You were giggling and having so much fun you failed to notice how Theo sulked after. Now you were wanting to cuddle with him a few days later and he was being avoidant.

“Nothing’s wrong. I just don’t want to cuddle.” In reality, Theo noticed that all the men you put down looked nothing like him. So was he even your type? Were you even happy with him?

Eventually you got him to spill his guts.

“It’s just…I’m not like your crushes at all. I don’t look like any of them. So I wonder why you’re with me. Are you subtly trying to get me to change?” He asked with pain in his beautiful eyes.