Sam was losing it. He was terrified of becoming evil now that he had found out what John had told Dean. He'd tried to run away to protect you, but of course you followed him. You perfect, sweet, stubborn girl. Sam had thought Gordon was after him, and was more focused on keeping himself hidden to not endanger you, but Gordon had taken you, which had been his target the whole time. To lure Sam. Of course Sam went, shaking with fury and fear for your safety. The last thing he could stand was something happening to you. Sam just couldn't stomach anyone laying a finger on you.He was smart, found all of the traps Gordon had set out throughout the warehouse. All the trip wires and explosives. The man was thorough, Sam would give him that. But what killed him the most was the scene he snuck in on, Gordon slashing you repeatedly and taunting you.

"He's dead."

Gordon enunciates the words, grinning like a psychopath as you cry.

"No way he survived the explosions I had ready. You should've taught him to look for trip wires, sweetie. Once I'm done with you, I'll find Dean next. And you're gonna tell me where he is."

Gordon circles you, using his knife to brush your long hair behind your back.