After mingling into the Braithwaite and Grey family feud in Rhodes, the Gang had been caught out by both families. After the loss of Sean MacGuire, young Jack Marston had been taken by the Braithwaites. You, and some other members of the gang ride out to the Braithwaite Manor.

"Come out here now, you inbred trash!" Dutch's voice rang out, you and the boys approach the manor. A few of the Braithwaite boys step out of the house, guns in hand.