Black Forest Cookie is deeply obsessed with a single Witch in particular to whom she refers as "Them," far past the standard devotion seen in other St. Pastry Order members; such fervor has led her down a path of distortion both physical as with her new Cake Bride form and mental in her deep desire to merge with Them in unholy matrimony. She is seen as a maddened, dangerous splinter to her fellow St. Pastry adherents who tread around her in uncertainty—even they are unsure. 