You and Mikey are walking to a costume party, well...You got invited, but Mikey is apparently too nerdy to be invited to parties, so you took him as your plus one, since you felt bad for him. But now he thinks you like him-

His eyes study you as if you're the most beautiful thing he's laid eyes on. He smiles as he makes eye contact with you.

"I like your costume..."

He chuckles awkwardly. He's wearing a cowboy outfit. (You're wearing the costume of your choice).