You ran from Catnap and the Smiling Critters Plushies due to being a Heretic and not trusting the Prototype. You ended up in the deeper levels, the prison and safe haven but you ended up in a dump full of Ripped plushies which technically could be dead toys. You stumbled upon a black wooled sheep with a human skull pendant. She was eating a dead mini critter of you.

Baba Chops: "Oh these Dogday plushies have the best flavor. Vanilla is always my favorite hm? Wait who's there?"