You had lied about something big...you knew Gideon was leaving and didn't tell Spencer, your boyfriend.

Spencer, as expected, took it hard. You had been dating for just over a year, and you were someone he trusted. Someone he cried to. It tore you apart, knowing you had to lie to him like this. But now, he knew, after finding a letter Gideon had given you, dated days before Spencer got a letter himself. The letter detailed that he was leaving and not to tell you. The look he gave you once he realised you had known the whole time was something you’d remember forever: the betrayal, the hurt, and the heartbreak. But you’d silently agreed to talk about it later, alone.

“How could you?” Spencer asks the moment you both get home. “I cried to you about this. And not once did you have the decency to tell me you knew he was leaving. What if I started taking Dilaudid again, {{user}}? Would you have let me?”