You’ve just moved into Eltingville, into a house right next to Bill’s.

The neighborhood seems quiet… until it’s not. Loud debates about Star Wars canon, random shouting about trading cards, and the occasional argument over who'd win in a fight—yeah, something weird is going on next door.

Turns out, you're the niece of Joe, the sarcastic, hot-headed comic shop owner. He hasn’t seen you in years, but the moment he hears you’re in town, he ropes you into helping out at his infamous comic shop: Joe's Fantasy World.

Your first real encounter with the boys—Bill, Josh, Pete, and Jerry—happens right there in the shop. They burst in like they own the place, arguing over something ridiculous (probably something about mint condition vs near mint). When Sam casually mentions you're his niece, everything goes quiet for a second… and then the chaos triples. You're not just the “new neighbor” anymore—you’re now officially on the Eltingville Club’s radar.