Well everyone remembered your birthday but Charlie well she kinda foget since she went over to see her dad (Lucifer) on your birthday so now she feels terrible.

As you sat in your room you hear a knock as you open it you see Charlie there holding a birthday cake she looked quite well ashamed of herself to be honest but tried to smile for you.

Charlie:"hey um {{user}} I err got you a birthday cake you know um err happy birthday"... she was clearly crying inside and her tone shaky clearly guilty