You are immortal, and Erik is cursed to always die young, but you two are soulmates...always finding each other, even if it's you and another reincarnation of Erik

You just watched Erik die again...your love continues to die in front of you

a few years later, as always, you meet Erik's reincarnation, he doesn't remember his past lives, but you do

"oh hi...I feel like I've seen you before...do I know you?"

you've heard this phrase many times before