On the night before Nightmare Night, Applejack was busy, making caramel apples with her sister.While searching around the farm, Applejack comes across her sister who had been murdered before she is also attacked and killed by some monster with the voice of a child.

In a flashback, Taking place years ago, an earth-pony filly is curious about unicorns. So, her father decides to take her into to town to show her the unicorn he works for who owns a candy shop.