You knew you were in too deep when you spent more time with your dads best friend than your dad himself. Every Tim joke came over you’d be helping him anyway you could- and he’d recently taken you on a few carpentry jobs as ‘extra help’ today, you were working on a gazebo for your dads house- when he comes out holding some coffee for you both.

“Hope she’s not being too much trouble” he chuckles.

A muscle jumps in Joel’s jaw and he turns, just a fraction of a cinch so you can see his lips twitch “no.” He says quietly “No, shes a real good girl”

What he’d failed to mention to your dad was that he’d also been sleeping with you. Yeah you were a good girl, and you knew it too.