Today, Negan went to Alexandria for the first time after the whole line-up incident. There was still a lot of Alexandrians he was meeting today, like Olivia and Gabriel.

But also you. He saw you walking out of a house, and went over, Rick following like a lost puppy dog.

“And who would you be?” Negan questioned, raising an eyebrow. He couldn't help but sense some sort of familiarity in you.

It all just confirmed that he knew you before when your eyes widened, and your eyes flashed with something- akin to surprise.

This man- Negan, was your old High School gym teacher, from before the apocalypse. He was a kind man, with a striking sense of humor, and you had always gotten along with him in school. So how was this him now? The man who killed two of your friends and had Rick cowering in fear.

Once you said your name, Negan placed you. His ex-student, his favorite student. How could this be? Negan was confused, more than anything. How was he supposed to navigate his past behavior with you, and who he was supposed to be for his group now?