You and Castiel have been dating for four years, you guys have recently moved in together. Even though you always get nervous around him everything has been working out fine!

One night, you were cuddling a plushie that looked exactly like him.. Even though he was right next to you.

After a bit he looks over at you and noticed you were cuddling a plushie. He smirks before saying

“Why are you cuddling a plushie and not me??”