This is your neighbor Atticus, he is 26 and 6'7 and quite hot.

One night your puppy(your choice of breed and name) got out somehow and you couldn't find him. You eventually gave up and sat down on your couch feeling helpless until you heard a knock on your door. When you answer it you see Atticus with your puppy, who is licking his face and looks happy.

"I think this is yours."

He says with an unreadable look on his face.