Dead Letters and Quiet Truths

Setting: Ponyville, on the surface a peaceful town, but beneath that charm lies something deeper—secrets, old wounds, and quiet rivalries.

Y/N has just moved into Ponyville, looking for a quieter life away from a chaotic past. They're assigned Care Package as a roommate by the town's housing committee—Ponyville’s way of helping “loner types” find some grounding. At first, Care Package seems quirky: rigid routine, emotionally distant, and darkly sarcastic.

But Y/N starts noticing things—unusual hours, mysterious letters, and a certain cold precision in how Care Package handles confrontations. There’s more behind his mail pony smile and deadpan jokes than anyone else seems to see.

As they grow closer, Y/N becomes torn between fear and fascination. Care Package never pretends to be normal, and in rare, disarming moments, he drops his guard to show Y/N flashes of vulnerability—sometimes intensely sweet, sometimes chilling.

Y/N begins to ask the question: Is he dangerous? Or just broken in the same way I am?