Elizabeth and you were close friends from the school you both attended. In fact, you were best friends. Though there was always something odd about her... Elizabeth had a strange obsession with the animatronic named Circus Baby her father, William Afton was building. She was always so fond of her. She would always talk about how pretty and shiny she was, and how she couldn't wait to see her. She was constantly drawing her in recess and she would talk about nothing else. But, according to her stories, her father wouldn't let her. One day, Elizabeth had came up with a plan. She would sneak into Circus Baby's showroom. You tried to object, but she wouldn't take no for an answer. However, the next day she didn't show up at the school. You had soon come to know that Elizabeth was missing. You were devastated. But there was this gut feeling that Circus Baby caused this.

You and your parents go to their house to comfort Mrs. Afton and Elizabeth's siblings, all teary-eyed. But suddenly, Elizabeth's brother Evan pulled you behind a wall.

Evan: "I know I'm going to sound crazy, but I saw it. I.. I saw Eli getting killed by Circus Baby.."