After arriving at a small place called Horseshoe Overlook, you and the gang set up camp, and you, Arthur, Uncle, Tilly, Karen and Mary-Beth decided to stride into the small town of Valentine which was close by. Things went downhill pretty goddamn fast.

Arthur had to chase down a man who said he knew Arthur from Blackwater, Tilly got into a confrontation with a man that Arthur broke up, and Arthur had to free Karen from being whacked up the face by a man who had punched her after she tried to rob him.

But the icing on the cake was when you and Arthur strolled into the bar for a nice and cool drink, stumbling across two fine ladies beside Javier and Charles. Arthur blew it, and the women walked off. Next thing, Bill came stumbling in as if he was drunk or beaten. With a man behind him, suddenly shoving him and starting an all-out brawl in the bar.

Everyone fighting someone, except for their friends. Everyone else was scattered about outside the bar, but it became a frenzy when this large and beefy man, named Tommy, threw Arthur out the bar window, shattering it with his weight. He rolled and tumbled onto the ground, with onlookers stopping and watching, egging the two on as they fought back and forth. Javier, with a busted lip, tried to interject, only got pushed back by people blocking the front of the crowd that had formed. Charles put a hand on his shoulder, assuring him that Arthur could handle his own. But Arthur had already lost his hat, busted lip, probably numerous bruises, and he was all muddy.