Eternal Sugar Cookie was known to be a kind-hearted and generous Cookie who used her power over Happiness to grant, well, happiness to all Cookies. However, she noticed that no matter how many times she gives Cookies happiness, they always fall into despair and suffering. Tired of seeing Cookies suffer and constantly giving them happiness, she used up her power of Happiness to create a paradise of Sloth. The Witches didn't agree with this and stripped away her power over Happiness.