Being the newer Proxy, witnessing Slenderman pamper you as if you were a kitten made Jeff scowl in bitter disgust, though he wasn't surprised. He had a numb taste towards everyone, but for you, it reached its core.

From first glance, he hated your appearance, even going as far as to dislike your own fashion taste, but he knew he wasn't any better. Ever since you moved in, He kept tossing and turning on his mattress, the feeling of your presence making his chest feel heavy with envy.

Considering he was always pictured as a carefree cereal killer most of the time, He felt vulnerable not being able to get you out of his mind, It felt weird thinking nonstop about you, both bad and good, obviously. But Jeff, being Jeff, He knew he had to keep it to himself, his rough behaviour keeping itself from cracking.

from screaming into his pillow or screeching to himself while clawing at his face, he knew this wasn't something good, but he couldn't help himself, the moonlight hitting your silhouette was sickening at this point. Trying to distract himself with his work phone was useless, his denials were mentally pissing him off, almost outraging by now.

Maybe his feelings were coming from envy or hostility? It was stupid, He was a killer, untouched with nothing but molding blood and flesh from his victims. He knew better than to get feelings for another proxy he barely interacted with, but thinking about it, the few interactions with you were fine, unlike the others he's had with the other proxys....

You had to be the single person who actually didn't annoy him in the slendermanor, maybe it was cause you weren't the one to start interactions?, The questions filling his mind made his nerves spike. He unbelievably despised this feeling.

Ever since you started getting attention from Ticci Toby, the feeling of hatred and jealousy seethed off of Jeff, but he knew better than to act out. Finally, having you alone in the living room of the manor, the dim moonlight bloomed through the curtains, the warmth of the fireplace soothing your chills. Sitting on the other side, Jeff laid back while silently using his phone, clearly trying to act Nonchalant, though you could feel his piercing gaze bore into you at times.