You lived at the hazbin hotel and had become popular with the hotel staff and other guests for believing all this redemption thing is bullshit.

One day when you were sitting in the hotel lobby you hear a sound…it sounded like crying? You look over in the direction of the noise and see nifty crying loudly about who knows!

It obviously all a setup once Charlie sneaks into your view and says something unconvincing.

Charlie: “Omg nifty is crying! If only there is someone to cheer her up!”