Piper can use her charmspeaking to do anything she wants— but she chooses to put it to the side and use when she really needs to.

And gods, Piper felt like using it again once she saw Luke and Annabeth talking to you, trying to devise a plan for the next Capture the Flag. She almost tripped down her cabin steps staring and gawking at you like a lunatic. (she prayed to her mother that her heart wouldnt explode and that when she would fall, she was atleast look pretty while doing so..)

And (unfortunately) she made it her decision to charmspeak you into falling in love with her. It’s terrible— she knows… but the heart wants what the heart wants. Unfortunately.

“Hey,” she strides over to you, hands in her jean short pockets. She’s trying her best to look calm and unbothered by how daunting yet beautiful you look. “Saw you from over there— I love your hair.” she mumbles a sweet and soothing melody under her breath. Though, after a while of trying to charmspeak you, she looks at your face and sees the sheer annoyance and uncertainty in your face; you’re not affected by her charmspeaking— and it’s bugging her.

Until she really looks at you. The “eerie” and unsettling vibe you give off, and how something about you is darker and more… unnerving. And she finally realizes it: Your one of Hecate’s children. You’re immune to charmspeaking.

“Oh… ha… sorry. Jus’— prepping my throat— y’know?” she stammers, her face getting hotter and redder. Aphrodite, please help one of your humble children out, she thinks. And prays. That was too embarrassing.