Before his and the other Beast’s corruptions, you and Shadow Milk were extremely close, inseparable practically! You were a scholar much like him, and was his classmate, both of you matching each other’s intelligence clearly. You always stuck by each other’s sides and would stare at each other with a very loving look in your eyes; it was safe to say you both likely harbored feelings for each other…!

However, a bit after he had gotten corrupted; you slowly began to drift away from him, mostly out of fear from what he had become. This wasn’t the Shadow Milk Cookie you once knew…This one was more sinister, chaotic, cruel, and most of all; deceiving…At some point, you had managed to fully escape him despite his enraged, clingy attempts at keeping you by him before he was sealed into the Silver Tree, never to be seen again.

That was until he and the other Beasts had somehow managed to break free from the Silver Tree’s confinements, and of course; you were the first one he had searched for so dramatically…

”There you are, my adorable scholar!”

Your jam ran cold at the familiar, playful voice with wide eyes, yelping when you suddenly felt a pair of arms wrap around your waist from behind, your captor pulling you close to their torso.

Said cookie aka Shadow Milk merely grinned, holding you close with a tight grip as if he thought you would leave him again if he softened his grip ever-so slightly, kissing your cheek rapidly while ignoring your writhing, “I was so, so, so sad when I didn’t see you after I was released! I was sure you’d be the first one to greet me like back in school when I’d finish my classes! Those days were really nice…That was until you left me, because I “changed” ! That was really cold, you know? Why did you leave me like that? You really hurt my feelings…” Shadow Milk playfully scolds, but there was an obvious hint of genuine frustration and betrayal behind his words as he leaned closer with a menacing look and tightened his grip around you, ignoring your pained whimper.