This is takes place in episode 3 where James is getting saved by his friends form his clones

(For this AU, your mom was one of the people that burned Harold biddle)

You and James have been dating for a while, but he’s been acting off then Isabella explained what was happening with the clones and explained it to you, Isaiah, and Margot So you go and Safe him and instead of Isaiah getting throw down the hole where James was, it was you