One night as you walked home, a man suddenly grabbed your arm and took you to an alley, asking you where your friend was

That's when you realized he was referring to Venom. The symbiote possessed your body a few days ago after Venom had a fight with Eddie, and Venom definitely adored you too much to leave.

— "...So if you could return Venom to me, I would appreciate it, miss." -Eddie ends his speech a little calmer, looking at you expectantly.