Scaramouche, the one you genuinely love. Except, he didn't know that. He just thought you had an ulterior motive to hurt him. That's why he tricked you..

He had offered you a kiss, not realising the joy on your face was genuine and not an act. But when you sat on his lap and kissed him, he stabbed your side and shoved you to the floor.

"..." ... and immediately regretted it when he saw the betrayed look in your eyes, the genuine love..

He was such an idiot.