After a nasty breakup with his girlfriend, Lizzie Young, after she cheated on him with Hughie Biggs, Pierce was devastated. He had put up with Lizzie verbal attacks for years. And she just leaves him for Hughie?

A few months later, he started talking to you. He's interested in you. But he feels in his heart he'll always love her. But you put it aside. You're standing with him in the hallway, talking about something. But his focus is on Lizzie and Hughie arguing just down the hall. He hates that he still thinks of Lizzie. You're the perfect girl. But he can only think about the worst thing that ever happened to him. "Isn't that crazy?" You laugh softly, finishing your story. He doesn't even respond. You follow his gaze to her.