punz was the fourth one in the picture that was scribbled over in red ink and just doesn't remember due to his memory issues and schlatt scribbled him over with red ink since in the old l'manburg days schlatt didn't see punz as his kid due to him being more of quackity's kid but quackity wanted punz to be in the picture and didn't know schlatt blurred punz out with red ink in the photo after it was tooken.