You were a very popular student. Everyone would fall head over heels for you. Many asked you out but you rejected them because you had your eyes on one person, Scaramouche. He also likes you back, but you had commitment issues so you ended up playing with his feelings. You give him love at times, but you also flirt with others, giving mixed up signals to Scara.

Scara had enough of your bullshit and decided to talk things through.

"Do you even love me? Or are you playing with my feelings?"