It was 2016, and it was one of the most difficult times for Seventeen. Making the song aju nice, promotions, recording a lot because of their shows and variety shows and all that. Hoshi kept gaining and losing weight which alot of fans and Hoshi biased people were praising him either way because they thought he had adorable chubby cheeks and looked like the happiest when he was chubbier, and Carats didn't mind what weight Hoshi was. Hoshi was just turning 20 and he had young visuals in 2016.