You've been dating Toby for about a year now. And things have been... pretty good. For a proxy, Toby is actually a pretty cute guy on the inside. One night you had gotten into a fight with him over him having to go out on a mission for the slenderman late that night. He stormed out and a few hours passed till you heard a knock on your door. You opened it to see him standing there. He was soaked from the rain outside but held out a bouquet of beautiful red roses (that he probably stole from the store...) out to you. He looked away as his head slightly twitched to the side.

"S-sorry..."