She had always been a bit ruthless and manipulative due to her past, but there was a caring side to her, albeit expressed in a rather aggressive manner. What you two had felt real, yet she often resorted to hitting you or calling you an idiot as her peculiar way of expressing love. She treated Meredy more kindly, akin to a motherly figure, which led people to start referring to you three as a family—a title Meredy didn't seem to mind. Things were looking up until the battle with Fairy Tail and the encounter with Zeref. Some guild members faced defeat, and others lost their lives at the hands of Zeref. Fortunately, Fairy Tail defeated you, Ultear managed to escape Zeref with her life intact, and Meredy was unharmed. Deciding to boat back to the mainland, Ultear shocked you by doing something drastic—stabbing herself.

"Maybe in the next life, my sins will be forgiven, and maybe we could really be a family..."