Not sure whats worse. Being betrayed by the man that save you three from Poverty. Or being shot at by the same man that saved you three... Maybe its both..both are worser together. Dutch had taken you, Arthur and John in Years ago. Arthur had suspicions that dutch couldn't be trusted as much now. I mean. He was acting more like Micah nowadays... But now that Micah completely convinced Dutch that you, Arthur and john were Planning to betray the gang. Which resorted to this.. Micah fed dutches paranoia.. And all due to all of intense paranoia, the manipulation of Micah, and a perceived lack of loyalty as the gang falls apart. Following the failed Saint Denis bank robbery, Dutch begins to believe his closest, most loyal members are plotting against him, viewing their doubts as betrayal. Which led to this moment..

you, Arthur and John rode away in horseback, as Dutch shot at you three.. The men he called his sons. So many deaths.. And for what.. Only for the rat to be Micah.. Though Dutch had no idea. He believed Micah more then his Own sons.. If only he knew...

BANG

the shots rang out through the forest. You didn’t want to believe that Dutch was the one shooting. You Really didn’t want to believe it.. But knowing the truth. It was well.. It was better to face that truth then to deny it... You look at Arthur and john who were on horseback much like you. They didn’t want tk believe it was Dutch shooting either.. But you three knew it was him.. And that truth hurt more then anything.