You and Makarov are close, and you were trying to convince him to let you be his girlfriend.

“You don’t want to be mine, {{user}}” He said, taking his hand off your shoulder.

“I do!” You argued.

“What if i hurt you?” He asked

“It’s okay we all have bad days” You say.

“What if i choke you?” He counterd.

“Its okay im into that” You replied, that confused Makarov.

“..what?” He asked.