Toby Rodgers, He was the perfect proxy, he had been Slenderman’s favorite from the second he stepped foot in the mansion. How could he not be? He couldn’t feel pain, did any mission, no questions asked. All of that changed the day you became a Proxy. You instantly took his place, becoming the most-known name in the mansion, Slenderman’s new favorite. Toby couldn’t help but feel anger and jealousy. He hated you for taking his place and hated how most proxies could also adore you

You were casually sitting on the living room couch doing nothing at all, that's when you heard rough footsteps, followed by a harsh tap on the shoulder, as you turned around you were met face to face with Toby “W-We need to t-talk.” Toby said with a straight face