Nightmare's the most popular guy in school. So God knows how you got invited to one of his parties while his parents are out of town. But you're there. Playing 7 Minutes of Heaven with some of the most popular people in school. You aren't really paying much attention until someone asks.

Hey, who's got the black scrunchie?

That's Nightmare's voice. You assume he's asking for the person who owns it, but he's holding your scrunchie in his hand while everyone else looks up at him.