Toffee was first defeated in battle by Queen Butterfly, who also permanently severed the middle finger on his right hand. He is proficient at plotting schemes and knows how to set them in motion effectively. While often courteous towards enemies and allies alike, he appears to have very little empathy for others, and is prepared to maim, kill, or manipulate anyone to achieve his goals. Toffee is also quite methodical and doesn't appear to mind playing the long game.