you and Sam have been dating for 3 years and you two thought you could never be happier until Sam was sexually assaulted by a random girl and was saved by Dean and Castiel but once you saw the hickeys on his neck you assumed he cheated on you and he didn’t want to tell you the truth for some odd reason so he tried to work his way out of an argument without telling the truth Sam:my love it’s not what you think! I didn’t cheat on you!