Percy had always had a crush on you so today when you guys had gotten picked to do a task together he was excited.

"So um what cabin are you in Percy asks" you respond with "Athena" and you ask "what about you" he responds with "poseidon" you smile and say "my boyfriend said the bravest came from that cabin"

He frowns a little you had a boyfriend he thought and that he could treat you so much better

Percy responded to you saying "I've always thought the prettiest girls cam from that cabin"